The Pros and Cons of In-House Cleaners vs Professional Services
If you’re the facility manager, the property manager or just the person who ends up in charge of the building, sooner or later you have to decide who’s going to do the cleaning. You can hire your own cleaner and keep it in-house, or you can outsource the work to a professional cleaning company.
We talked through both sides on this episode of the Cleaning Indy Podcast. This page goes further than the episode. It compares the two side by side, adds up what an in-house cleaner really costs, and covers the downsides of outsourcing too.
Here’s the short version. If you already have an in-house cleaner who you trust, who shows up and does great work, keep them. If you’re the one covering sick days, hiring again every few months or hearing about the cleaning from your boss, it’s worth looking at a cleaning company.
In-house cleaners and cleaning companies, side by side
| In-house cleaner | Cleaning company | |
|---|---|---|
| Hiring | You advertise, interview and hire, and you start over when someone quits. | The company hires, and it replaces anyone who leaves. |
| Sick days and vacations | The cleaning waits, or your staff pitch in. | A good company sends a trained fill-in. |
| Training | You train them, or you count on what they learned somewhere else. | Every cleaner learns the company’s system. |
| Supervision | Usually the facility manager, on top of everything else. | A good company inspects the work. With AFC, every clean also gets a GPS check-in and photos. |
| Equipment and chemicals | You buy, store and replace them. | Usually included, but ask when you compare quotes. |
| Payroll, taxes and insurance | Yours to handle. | The company’s. AFC is bonded and insured. |
| Knowing the person | You already know them, and they know your building. | You’ll get to know a new team. |
The pros of keeping your cleaning in-house
There’s a lot going for an in-house cleaner, especially one who’s been with you for a while.
You already know them, and you probably like and trust them. Someone who comes from an outside company is a stranger at first, and it takes time to get to know them.
You also know their habits, like whether they show up on time, and they’re already part of your company. HR has their paperwork and tax forms, payroll is set up, and you probably have a file on how they’ve done.
They may get along well with everyone in the building. That matters whether your cleaning is in-house or outsourced.
And they may simply be great cleaners. Some people bring real experience with them, sometimes from working at a professional cleaning company, where they were properly trained in good techniques and procedures. If that’s who you have now and it’s working, you have everything that you need, and you don’t need to outsource.
The cons of in-house cleaning
Even with a great cleaner, there are a few things to think about, mostly for the person who does the hiring, training and scheduling. That’s usually a facility manager or director who’s also looking after the building itself, any equipment in it and a full calendar of maintenance.
Cleaners are hard to hire
Plenty of employers are competing for the same workers. When we recorded this episode in 2023, fast food restaurants around Central Indiana were already paying $15 or $16 an hour. Higher wages are good for workers, but if you run a facility on a budget, it means going back to your bosses for more money just to keep the position filled. And every time someone quits, the hiring starts over.
Someone has to cover sick days, personal days and vacations
Vacations are usually planned, so you can prepare for them. Sick days aren’t, and a personal day is a personal day. When your cleaner calls in, the work doesn’t go away. Somebody still has to restock the paper products in the restrooms, empty the trash before it overflows and clean up the break room, including the microwave and the fridge. The high-touch surfaces still need to be sanitized, and the dusting still needs to happen every week.
Most of the time, that lands on the facility manager, and it pulls everyone else away from the work that they were hired to do. Your coworkers get frustrated, they mention it to your boss, and eventually it comes back to you. It throws off your own schedule too. Maybe today was the day that you were going to replace all of the HVAC filters, and now that gets pushed back a week because your cleaner has the flu.
It’s even harder with a VIP visit coming up. You can plan for that three weeks ahead and ask for all hands on deck, but nobody can plan around a virus. If you have more than one cleaner, they can split up the work when someone is out. With only one, nobody is there to get the building ready.
Training is on you
How much training does it take to empty trash or dust? Not much. Restrooms, break rooms and the things that people touch all day are different, because cleaning them well is about hygiene. When staff fill in, they understandably think about the task in front of them, like emptying the trash or vacuuming around a desk, and germs aren’t on their mind.
What an in-house cleaner really costs
When you compare a cleaning company’s price with an in-house cleaner, it’s tempting to put the contract price next to an hourly wage. That isn’t a fair comparison, because the wage is only part of what you pay.
In May 2025, the median wage for janitors and cleaners in the Indianapolis area was $17.72 an hour, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. That’s about $36,850 a year for a full-time cleaner. On top of the wage, you’ll pay for:
- Social Security and Medicare taxes, which add 7.65% to every dollar of wages
- Federal and Indiana unemployment insurance
- Workers’ compensation insurance
- Paid time off and any benefits that you offer
- Covering the days when your cleaner is out, because the cleaning still has to get done
- Vacuums, mops, buckets and cleaning chemicals, plus a place to store them
- The time that it takes to hire, train and supervise, which usually comes out of the facility manager’s week
- Hiring and training all over again when someone quits
Add those up for a year and compare the total with a cleaning company’s price for the same work. When you get quotes, ask what’s included, such as equipment, chemicals and paper products, so that you’re comparing the same things.
The benefits of outsourcing your janitorial services
You get your time and your sanity back
When the cleaning is going well, it slides down your list, because there’s always something louder pushing its way to the top. The squeaky wheel gets the grease.
Back when I was a facility director at a school, before I had a Treo 650, I carried a notepad with a pen stuck in the metal ring. I couldn’t walk down a hallway without teachers stopping me to add something to the list, and it got almost comical. A work order system helped a lot once we set one up, but cleaning that was going well still never made it to the top of my list. When you outsource, keeping the cleaning on track becomes the cleaning company’s job.
Hiring and training become our job
We know how hard cleaners are to hire, because it took us about eight years to build a hiring system that we’re happy with. When you outsource, the ups and downs of hiring are the cleaning company’s problem, and so is the training. Everyone who cleans your building has been through the same training.
A trained fill-in covers when a cleaner is out
For most facility managers, this is the biggest difference. A cleaning company can bring in extra people when someone is out. We keep fill-in cleaners ready, and because all of our cleaners learn the same system, a fill-in already knows how we clean a restroom or a break room. When we start in a new building, we bring a few extra people through during the first week. That way, more than one person knows the building, and a fill-in won’t need you to show them around.
Fewer complaints reach your boss
When the cleaning gets done on every scheduled day, your coworkers don’t have to chip in, and they aren’t taking empty paper towel dispensers and overflowing trash cans to your boss. Your boss knows that the building will be ready when a VIP visits, even if the regular cleaner is sick that day.
Cleaners who are trained for hygiene
A professional company trains for more than what you can see. In restrooms we use what we call the hygienic way of cleaning, which is meant to get rid of bacteria and germs along with the mess. Germs also build up on the surfaces that people touch all day, like desks, tables, break room counters, door handles and even the turntable in the microwave. Fewer germs can mean fewer people out sick, which we covered in The Impact of Office Cleaning on Employee Productivity and Morale.
We keep up with industry standards from groups like ISSA, the cleaning industry’s trade association, and with health guidelines from the CDC. It shows up in small habits too, like hanging the mop up to dry instead of leaving it sitting in the bucket.
Standards that you can check
Before we start, we go through a scope of work with you that spells out everything that you want cleaned, line by line, and how often. Our software turns it into a checklist in the app that each cleaner uses, which is also where they clock in and out and find your building’s instructions, like how to set the alarm, which lights to turn off and how to lock up. When we inspect, we score the work against that same list. Every clean gets a GPS check-in and photos, and we send you the inspection reports.
We clean three, four or five days a week, during the day or in the evening, and you can change the scope of work any time.
Equipment, chemicals and insurance are taken care of
A cleaning company brings its own commercial equipment and cleaning chemicals, so you aren’t buying, storing and replacing them. Payroll taxes and insurance for the cleaners are the company’s job too, and AFC is bonded and insured.
The downsides of outsourcing, and what to ask about them
A fair comparison has to cover the other side too. Here’s what can go wrong with a cleaning company, and the questions that help you avoid it.
You don’t pick the cleaner yourself
You won’t hire the person who cleans your building, and at first you won’t know them the way that you’d know your own employee. Ask who will be cleaning your building, how the company decides which cleaner is the right fit for it, and what happens if it isn’t working.
Quality can slip after the first few months
Some companies start strong and fade, which is one of the most common reasons that businesses switch cleaning companies. We talked about it in Help! My Cleaners Quality Dropped After Initial 90 Days. Ask how often the company inspects, and whether you’ll see the results.
A low bid can mean a rushed clean
If a price looks low, ask how the company worked out how many hours your building needs. When too much square footage and too many restrooms get packed into one shift, the math doesn’t work and corners get cut. Our pricing is based on ISSA standards for how long cleaning tasks take.
A contract price looks higher than a wage
A cleaning company’s price covers the wages, taxes, insurance, equipment, training, supervision and fill-ins, so it will look higher than one person’s hourly rate. Compare it with the full cost of an in-house cleaner from the list above.
The cleaner who kept hiding in the janitor’s closet
Some problems can happen whether your cleaning is in-house or outsourced. We were training a new hire in November 2026 when she told us about a coworker at her last cleaning company who was always hiding somewhere during her shifts, including in the janitor’s closet. Our new hire had never imagined that someone would do that. Looking back, she thinks it’s kind of funny, but it wasn’t funny at the time, because it put more stress on the rest of the cleaners. It’s the third time that we’ve heard a story like that.
It can happen to anyone at any time, with your own staff or with a cleaning company. The benefit of outsourcing is that the company manages the people for you. A good cleaning company has somebody else on call who’s trained up and ready to go. If they need to replace someone, that person can step up to the plate and take the open spot.
We talked about why cleaners end up hiding in the closet, and how to stop it, in our episode Your Building Isn’t Clean (Here’s Why). Most of the time it comes down to unclear task lists, poor training, and no time tracking or inspections.
Questions that we hear about in-house and outsourced cleaning
Is it cheaper to hire our own cleaner?
Sometimes, especially for a small building that one part-time person can keep up with. Once you add payroll taxes, insurance, equipment, chemicals, coverage for sick days and the time that it takes to hire and supervise, the difference is usually smaller than the wage makes it look. Compare a full year of both.
What happens when our regular cleaner is out?
With an in-house cleaner, the work waits or your staff cover it. With us, a trained fill-in covers the shift, and they’ve been through the same training as your regular cleaner.
How do we know that the cleaning was done?
Every clean gets a GPS check-in and photos, and we send you inspection reports that are scored against your scope of work.
How hard is it to switch from in-house cleaning to a cleaning company?
It starts with a free walkthrough. We learn about your building and what you need, then we follow up with our plan and pricing. If you go ahead, a few extra people learn your building during the first week. There’s more about switching in our episode Effortlessly Transition To A Commercial Cleaning Vendor!
Get a plan and pricing for your building
If you’re weighing the two, book a free walkthrough. There’s no pressure and no obligation, and afterward we’ll follow up with a plan and pricing that you can compare with what in-house cleaning costs you today.
You’ll find more episodes like this one on our podcast page. To stay updated and learn more about commercial cleaning, visit our website at Cleaning Indy. Don’t forget to leave a review wherever you listen to this podcast, whether it’s on Google, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube.
